Subtotal
$0.00
All orders ship within 48 hours.
Mom-owned by a Tooth Fairy of 10+years
Endorsed by Pediatric dentists
Real-world tested and child-approved
What’s inside
Ahoy Matey is a pirate-themed Tooth Fairy gift set for children ages 4 to 12, crafted from brass, glass, and metal with no plastic.
It replaces cash across three visits with keepsake treasures such as a metal pirate coin, a real shell, a ship in a bottle, and a working brass compass.
Each treasure arrives in a gold bag with fairy dust and a fairy letter about bravery. Loved by boys and girls with an adventurous spirit, it makes a lost tooth feel like buried treasure.
Best for: kids who love pirates, treasure, and adventure, and parents who want a gift instead of cash.
Not ideal for: children under 3, or those wanting a gentle or princess theme.
3 Tiny Tooth Fairy letters
In sparkly envelopes with a positive life lesson tucked in (1 per gift)
3 Ready-to-Gift Bags
To hold each Tooth Fairy treasure
Plus Fairy Dust!
To sprinkle lightly (as you wish)
Why Kids Love It
- Surprise-filled moments kids can’t wait for
- Interactive, hands-on magic that feels real
- Beautiful keepsakes they’ll want to show off
Parent Perks
- Each kit covers up to 3 fairy visits (less planning!)
- Clear, step-by-step setup guides
- Quality materials that last
Good to Know
- Age-friendly: 4–12 yrs (parental discretion)
- Small parts included—store safely
- Reuse elements to stretch the magic
Frequently Asked Questions
This item includes 3 fairy visits. No extra purchases needed, everything you need to deliver magic is included within your package.
Everything you need to deliver magic is included within the package. No extra purchases needed—just open and deliver the magic.
Yes! All items are child-safe and tested for magic and believability. Note: small items are not suitable for children under 3.
We stand behind every product. If you’re not 100% satisfied, we’ll make it right. Contact us at myfairy@holdthemagic.com.
No problem! Hold The Magic gifts add excitement and “proof” of the Tooth Fairy’s visit. You can also leave money in the gift bag for a smooth transition. It’s been our experience that once they receive the tiny gifts, they don’t miss the money.
It’s smart to share your Hold The Magic plan with your child’s other guardian. Send a gift bag along in case the tooth falls out while they’re away!
As Seen On
